Best Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin – 2018 Reviews & Product Guide

There are plenty of areas of your skin that are particularly sensitive, and the skin around your eyes is one of the most vulnerable.

Even if your skin is otherwise pretty hardy, you’re likely to experience more sensitivity to sunlight and skin care products around your eyes.

Eye creams can treat some problems, so before you purchase a product you should pinpoint which specific issues you would like to target:

Fine lines and wrinkles may form in the creases of your eyes and above your cheekbones. You probably don’t think about this often, but the skin around your eyes moves as often as the skin around your mouth do whenever you make a facial expression or squint in bright sunlight.

Redness and puffiness can occur when fluids gather beneath your eyes. (It sounds strange, but we promise that even though it’s annoying, this is normal!)

Dark undereye circles is a symptom usually associated with a lack of sleep. Some people are genetically predisposed to getting dark circles, but they can also be an indication of built up blood (gross, we know, but even healthy!) or unusually thin skin.

Sensitivity or irritation might occur if you use skin care products with fragrances or reactive ingredients.

Dryness can also lead to excessive levels of irritation, as well as the appearance of red or flaky skin near your eyes.

There are a wide variety of over the counter treatments for all of these symptoms, which are relatively common even for people with otherwise healthy levels of skin sensitivity, but if you have particularly sensitive skin, then you may experience adverse reactions to products that might work well for other consumers.

Additionally, if you only have issues with dark undereye circles, you may not want (or need) a product that also minimizes wrinkles. It’s mainly famous for people with sensitive skin to choose their skin care products with more excellent care so that they do not introduce unnecessary active ingredients into their complexion.

Many of these symptoms could also be minimized merely by ensuring that you get enough sleep, as exhaustion often increases the appearance of characteristics like puffiness or dark undereye circles, but your beauty sleep isn’t the only contributing factor in these conditions so getting enough winks may not be enough to keep them at bay.

If you experience any of these symptoms, or others associated with the skin near your eyes, and haven’t had much luck finding products that are compatible with your sensitive skin, look no further than this list!.

Product

Feature / Benefit

Our Rating

Price

Lock in your skin’s natural moisture and nourish dehydrated skin

It’s “fix-all” approach to keeping the skin in your eye area healthy and hydrated

superfood for your skin

Specifically designed to brighten dark eye circles

The art & science of skincare

Ability to deliver supreme hydration

It goes on smoothly without feeling like you’re going to a ton of product

Great moisturizing product that doesn’t have a ton of extra ingredients

One purchase will last you a long time

Keep your colored circles from making you look anything less than entirely fresh.

1. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream

Neutrogena’s Hydro Boost product line carries just three products, all designed with one goal in mind: to lock in your skin’s natural moisture and nourish dehydrated skin, keeping it healthy and fresh rather than dull and dried-out. 

One of the key ingredients in the Hydro-Boost formula is hyaluronic acid, which occurs naturally in the skin. This compound can hold up to 1,000 times its weight in water and deliver that moisture directly to your skin cells upon contact! A small amount of olive extract helps to serve as a protective barrier that helps your skin to maintain its moisture throughout the day.

Unlike the other products in the Hydro Boost line, Neutrogena developed this eye gel specifically to be gentle enough to use near your eyes. In fact, this product can even be used on your eyelids or along your lash line! Its oil-free won’t smear into your eyes as it dries, and because it’s also the fragrance-free formula, it won’t irritate your eyes from being in such proximity.

Other products may target a variety of symptoms, but this gel is a no-muss, no-fuss product if you just need a little extra hydration!

How To Use It:

Before putting on makeup, apply a small amount to your dry eye areas (under eyes, along with the lash line, on eyelids, or at eye creases) and allow to dry.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    High if you primarily experience dryness or irritation near your eyes, and aren’t too concerned about other issues
    Fragrance-free!
  • thumbs-o-down
    Won’t be a fix-it-all product if you’re dealing with multiple issues.

2. LilyAna Naturals Rosehip & Hibiscus Eye Cream Moisturizer

LilyAna’s eye cream moisturizer is a gem. It’s “fix-all” approach to keeping the skin in your eye area healthy and hydrated seems unlikely for a product designed for sensitive skin, but its essential ingredients do all the heavy lifting. 

Rosehip seed oil stimulates your skin’s natural ability to regenerate, reducing the appearance of discoloration and wrinkles. And hibiscus flower extract nourishes your skin to promote firm surface and improve its elasticity. Impressively, this killer combination also brightens, plumps, and lifts the skin beneath your eyes to help your skin look young and healthy. What’s not to love about that?

Those of you who prefer to use vegan products are in luck: this eye moisturizer is USDA Organic Certified, and 100% cruelty-free. That’s right - ZERO animal testing. And still, AnaLily has created a formula gentle enough to use twice a day to finally reduce troublesome symptoms like wrinkles, puffiness, bags, and redness.

In fact, LilyAna is so confident that you’ll be in love with your skin after using this product that they offer a 30-day money-back guarantee. So what do you have to lose?

How To Use It:

Apply cream in small dots on upper lid beneath your eyebrows and below the eyes, taking care not to apply too close to the eyes. Gently pat in milk until it is completely absorbed. Allow setting for several minutes before continuing your makeup routine.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Can also be used to address wrinkles or under eye bags
    All-natural vegan product
  • thumbs-o-down
    Needs some time to set before you can apply makeup

3. Era Organics 10-in-1 Complete Facial Moisturizer

Era Organics markets its 10-in-1 moisturizer as “superfood for your skin.” It boasts a long list of ingredients ranging from Manuka honey to vitamin B to blue, green algae (yes, indeed) to hemp seed oil. 

Though you’d think that all of those ingredients would aggravate skin sensitivity, this moisturizer’s hypoallergenic formula is specially designed for sensitive skin of all types.

Era Organics has developed a product designed to deliver moisture to the base layers of your skin - not just its surface - to supply the nutrients that your skin needs to replenish itself from this inside out.

This means that, in addition to helping your skin to stay hydrated for up to 12 hours, this moisturizer can stimulate the growth of new skin cells, strengthen your skin, and improve elasticity to deliver potent anti-aging effects. Though this moisturizer can be used on any part of your face, it is gentle enough to use in your eye area.

Still overwhelmed by how many ingredients this jar holds? Era Organics has developed this product to *exactly* match the skin’s natural pH level to minimize sensitivity and adverse effects. Even gentle products typically don’t come close to matching this type of balance.

How To Use It:

Rub a dime-sized amount of the moisturizer into your skin until completely absorbed. Gentle enough to be used twice daily, and can be used in any part of the body as desired.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Delivers long-lasting moisture
    Designed to match your skin’s pH levels to minimize sensitivity
  • thumbs-o-down
    Has a lingering fragrance
    Is an all-facial moisturizer that can be used around the eyes rather than specially designed for eye use

4. Murad Renewing Eye Cream

Murad makes a TON of skincare products, from cleansers and serums to masks and supplements, to treat concerns from standard acne control to skin sensitivity. 

Spas and salons around the country use and trust the Murad brand, so if you are hesitant to try drugstore brands or something you’ve never heard of, you can take comfort in Murad’s well-established reputation.

A number of its products are sold under an “anti-aging” tag, and this renewing eye cream falls into this category. It is specifically designed to brighten dark eye circles to give you that youthful glow, and a clinically proven rejuvenating peptide to increase firmness and reduce the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines.

Users noted visible improvements after just a single use. They also indicate that a little bit of product can go a long way, which always a benefit for salon-brand products; this cream is more expensive than many products on this list, so it’s nice to know that you’ll be getting a solid bang for your buck!

How To Use It:

After using your usual cleansing and toning products, gently massage a small amount of product beneath your eye until fully absorbed. Maximize your results by following up with a moisturizer.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Helps to reduce symptoms of aging (crow’s feet, dark circles)
    Salon-brand product that professionals trust
  • thumbs-o-down
    Salon-brand products come at salon-brand prices

5. BAEBODY Beauty Eye Gel

BAEBODY Beauty brands its products as “the art & science of skincare,” and it’s easy to see why when you take a look at the ingredients that they use. Their eye gel is no exception. A few noteworthy examples:

Matrixyl 3000, which is intended to double your skin’s natural collagen production and protect it from free radicals that cause wrinkles and fine lines.

Plant stem cells, which help to increase your skin’s overall strength and resistance to sun damage.

How many other products have you heard of using plant stem cells? Pretty cool stuff.

The bottom line is that this combination of ingredients makes up an all-purpose cocktail that supercharges your skin. Have dark circles under your eyes? Red, puffy eyelids? Dry skin? Crow’s feet? General dullness or uneven skin tone around your eyes? BAEBODY Beaty’s eye gel targets ALL of these concerns and more, all without the use of any filler ingredients or fragrances. Best of all, this product can be applied underneath your usual makeup routine without looking greasy or messing with the staying power of your foundation or eye makeup!

How To Use It:

Pat product onto your eye, forehead, or cheek areas twice daily. Can also be used as a complete facial treatment, and under makeup products.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Contains a unique cocktail of ingredients, setting it apart from other market products.
  • thumbs-o-up
    All-purpose product that will target a variety of concerns.
  • thumbs-o-down
    Maybe hard to pinpoint how your skin will react to the unique blend of active ingredients.

6. Perricone MD Hypoallergenic Firming Eye Cream

I know what you’re thinking: How could a product with “MD” in its name possibly be gentle enough for me to use on my sensitive skin? I’ll tell you why. 

This hypoallergenic firming cream is made with a few key ingredients - specifically, extracts from the olive fruit and olive leaf - that were patented by Dr. Perricone to product therapeutic and regenerative benefits unique to Perricone MD products.

The Perricone MD brand produces its best results if you also follow an anti-inflammatory diet and take nutritional supplements that benefit skin health, but even if you don’t have the time or the energy to take those extra steps this product can produce killer results.

Its ability to deliver supreme hydration makes it ideal for users with unusually dry skin, and it’s even gentle enough to be used after cosmetic procedures with a minimal risk of adverse effects. User reviews can vouch for the fragrance-free, irritation-free application, and note with pleasure that this cream goes on smoothly beneath makeup for all-day wear!

How To Use It:

Apply along the contours of the eye area twice daily. Pat gently until product is fully set.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Compatible with extra dry skin.
  • thumbs-o-up
    Gentle enough to use after cosmetic procedures.
  • thumbs-o-up
    Patented formula.
  • thumbs-o-down
    Comes in a small container man may need to be frequently replaced.

7. Burt’s Bees Eye Cream

Burt’s Bees makes a range of lip balms and chapsticks that have turned the brand into a household name among millennials, so you’re probably familiar with their “99% natural” commitment to ann-natural ingredients. 

This is precisely what makes the Burt’s Bees eye cream perfect for users with sensitive skin!

Dark circles, bags, and wrinkles are at the top of many people’s lists for reasons that they look for eye cream products. But what if you just have dry skin, or want to correct some redness or puffiness? Do you need a product that contains a ton of ingredients for a skin problem that you don’t have? Probably not. In that case, this eye cream could be a great bet to meet your needs.

This cream is super lightweight, so it goes on smoothly without feeling like you’re going to a ton of product. 

Its goal is simple: to infuse your skin with the extra moisture that it needs to stay hydrated, which in turn helps to reduce puffiness and redness around your eyes. As a bonus, the eye cream also contains cotton extract to protect your skin against potential irritants, which may even include your other skincare products.

How To Use It:

Set small dots of the cream around your eye area and gently smooth. Gentle enough to be used twice daily.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    It’s easy to buy products from brands you already love*
  • thumbs-o-up
    Works excellent as a no-fuss moisturizing product
  • thumbs-o-up
    *Because, let’s be real, you probably already use their lip balm
  • thumbs-o-down
    Not designed to treat a wide range of concerns.

8. Pure Soothing Eye Balm

As a person with sensitive skin myself, I’ve used several Simple products over the years, and haven’t been disappointed. 

Simple was one of the first drugstore brands that I’d heard of to specifically market to people with sensitive skin, and so their makeup remover wipes wound up being a staple in my bathroom drawer. I’m happy to report that, even with my crazy sensitive skin, I’ve never had any reaction to Simple products.

Much like the Burt’s Bees eye cream detailed above, Simple’s soothing eye balm is a great moisturizing product that doesn’t have a ton of extra ingredients. If you’re looking for a to-the-point product to relieve dry eyes or puffiness, then this could be an excellent option for you.

 The product formula contains a blend of shea butter and jojoba oil to soothe and hydrate your skin, as well as additional vitamins to deliver a little extra nourishment with every use.

And, as is typical of Simple products, there aren’t any dyes or fragrances to irritate your eyes. Consider this product next up on my list of Simple products to try (and probably love).

How To Use It:

Gently smooth onto eye area until thoroughly blended.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Won’t break the bank.
  • thumbs-o-up
    Very useful when used as a pure moisturizing product.
  • thumbs-o-down
    Not useful for treating more severe concerns.

9. Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper Eye Balm

One of the best things about the Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper eye balm is that one purchase will last you a long time. Lots of cosmetic products come in tiny bottles and tubes and need to be replaced on a regular basis if you use them frequently; not so for the Peeper Keeper!

Even better, the Peeper Keeper eye balm can address a ton of issues that you might be experiencing in your eye area thanks to its range of all-natural ingredients, including Vitamin E and ten oils and extracts.

The profoundly penetrating formula nourishes skin more profound than just to top later, helping to keep dryness, redness, puffiness, and fine lines at bay.

It also reduces the appearance of dark circles beneath your eyes, restores (or maintain) your youthful glow, and stave off age-related damage.

Bonus:

This little balm is the perfect size to stash in your purse for whenever your peepers need a little pick-me-up.

How To Use It:

After cleansing, apply to skin around the eye area. Be careful to avoid contact with your eyes. Apply makeup as normal.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Lasts a long time, so you won’t have to replace your purchase constantly.
  • thumbs-o-up
    Works as a catch-all product for a range of eye area issues.
  • thumbs-o-down
    Application can be a little oily.

10. Amara Organics Total Repair Eye Gel

This product does treat more than just the dark circles under your eyes, but its other beneficial effects are pretty much a result of the steps that the Total Repair eye gel takes to keep your colored circles from making you look anything less than entirely fresh.

Dark eye circles are commonly associated with not getting enough sleep. This is a contributing factor, but not for the reasons that you might think.

What you see in those dark circles is blood from the veins beneath your eyes, which you can see because your skin in that area is so thin. The color becomes more apparent as we age and when we are fatigued because that’s when the skin regenerates less effectively.

Enter the Amara Organics Total Repair eye gel. This product’s formula is designed to boost your skin’s collagen production so that it can naturally regenerate as it’s supposed to.

It also brightens and tightens the skin beneath your eyes, minimizing bags and sags to keep your skin as fresh as possible and cutting off some of the causes of your dark circles. User reviews have success stories of immediate boosts and long-term success at lightening up those dark circles! And, as an extra perk, it pretty efficiently reduces puffiness as well.

How To Use It:

Allow face to be dry after cleansing and applying toner (if you use one). Dab the eye gel around eyes. Follow with a moisturizer if needed.

Pros

Cons

  • thumbs-o-up
    Works great at getting rid of your dark, tired circles.
  • thumbs-o-up
    Removes makeup and cleanses your face in one step.
  • thumbs-o-down
    Not an instant fix; most effective when used consistently over time.

Final Thoughts

Whatever product you ultimately choose, keep in mind the following pro tips:

Whenever you try a new product around your eyes, be sure to start with the minimal product to reduce the risk of irritation. These products are specifically designed for sensitive skin but introducing new products to your skin care regimen always carries some risk of irritation, particularly in the eye area.

Use your ring finger when you apply any kind of product beneath your eyes. This goes for all of these eye creams as well as any foundation or moisturizer you might use. Your ring finger is the weakest of all your fingers, which means that you won’t be able to exert much force on the skin around your eyes. This is important because tugging at that sensitive surface can increase the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines as you get older.

Best of luck!

Trysh
 

Trysh Sutton is a wife, mother, attorney, interior decorator, strategic leader and teacher. She has an eye for business, innovation and perfection – and a desire to help her family, her friends and herself live a healthy and happy life.